This is an archive of past PWBC content. For current news and resources, visit peopleswaterboard.org.

DWSD’s Lifeline Plan for Water Affordability Misses the Mark

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASENews from the People’s Water Board Coalition June 28, 2022 Contact: Lynna Kaucheck, lynna@progressmichigan.org DWSD’s Lifeline Plan for Water Affordability Misses the MarkPlan fails to address Detroit’s most vulnerable populations DETROIT – Today, the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD) presented their pilot Lifeline Plan for Water Affordability to the Board of Water Commissioners, which approved the plan unanimously after many public comments asking the Board to wait at least 45 days for broad community engagement. The People’s Water Board Coalition released the following statement in response: “While we appreciate that DWSD and the Board of Water Commissioners (BoWC) have finally realized that Detroiters both need and deserve a water affordability plan; what was approved today is not based on facts and doesn’t accurately address the challenges that Detroiters have been facing for nearly two decades. Further, DWSD did not meet with the People’s Water Board Coalition to discuss this plan nor have they provided us with the actual plan. “An inclining tiered rate water plan is not a true water affordability plan, and it will not appropriately address the city’s most vulnerable populations. The Lifeline plan put forward by DWSD is a low-rate ration plan, i.e., income-eligible customers can use up to 4,500 gallons of water per month before they are charged at higher rates for additional usage. The Detroit City Council should review the rate restructuring proposal for equity and fairness, especially as infrastructure costs rise. “The devastating COVID-19 pandemic and unaffordable housing crisis have forced Detroiters to move in with friends and family members, thereby filling homes with multiple families and water users. DWSD’s estimated daily usage of 37 gallons per person is very underestimated. Actual usage is closer to two to three times higher than that (as estimated by the city of Philadelphia) which will put more households in higher rate tiers. Therefore, they will not benefit from the Lifeline plan. “A true water affordability plan is based on income, like the plan approved by Detroit City Council in 2005, and is based in fact and addresses root causes. We welcome the opportunity to work with DWSD and the Board of Water Commissioners to improve this plan, to create an authentic water affordability plan, and we will hold BoC accountable to their word that ‘we can make it better and we will.’ Our goal has always been to ensure that all Detroiters have access to safe, affordable drinking water and sanitation and we will continue to fight to make that happen.” PWBC calls upon the Detroit City Council to review today’s decisions by the DWSD Board of Water Commissioners before the rate restructuring and Lifeline plans are implemented.

Read More »

Water Ceremony and Press Conference Monday March 21, 11:30am

People’s Water Board Coalition Water Ceremony and Press Conference Monday…For Immediate Release Media Advisory Friday, March 18, 2022 Contact: Sylvia Orduño, 734.846.9465, smorduno@gmail.com Faith Leaders Call for Water Bills Based on Ability to Pay to End ShutoffsSpirit of Detroit Press Conference highlights moral crisis of water insecurity on eve of World Water Day DETROIT – Monday morning, a variety of faith leaders from Metro Detroit will gather at the Spirit of Detroit to call on mayors, and other elected leaders to adopt income based water bills and use American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds to keep water affordable for low income households. Members of the People’s Water Board Coalition Interfaith Justice Committee (IJC) will speak out the day before World Water Day, a global observation of water as a basic and crucial human need. Leaders of many faiths will focus on the moral crisis evident when people are denied water because the bills are too expensive. The pandemic and the ensuing economic downturn made the need for water more obvious and urgent, but even before the pandemic, low income families and individuals needed income based water bills. What: Press Conference on the Moral Crisis of Water Insecurity Who: People’s Water Board Coalition Interfaith Justice CommitteeRev. Kenita HarrisSister Mary Ellen HowardImam Mikail Steward-SaadiqRev. Bill Wylie KellermannElder Mary LloydRabbi Nate DeGrootNasy SankagiriSylvia Orduño – People’s Water Board Coalition When: Monday, March, March 21, 11:30 a.m. Where: Spirit of Detroit

Read More »

An Important PWB Announcement!

***MEDIA ADVISORY*** ACLU and NAACP Legal Defense Fund to Hold Wednesday Virtual Press Conference on Detroit Water Shutoffs Lawsuit and Ongoing Fight for Affordable Water CONTACT: Dana Chicklas, (734) 945-8857, dchicklas@aclumich.org WHAT:The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan (ACLU) and NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc. (LDF) legal team will be in court Feb. 3 at 9:30 a.m. to oppose a motion to dismiss our class action lawsuit demanding a permanent end to water shutoffs in Detroit and the institution of a meaningful water affordability program for low-income residents. A virtual press conference will immediately follow the hearing to update the media about the case, as well as the ongoing advocacy of the coalition of civil rights organizations to not only make water affordable for Detroit residents, but all people in Michigan. This lawsuit, filed in July 2020, is the latest in the coalition’s ongoing effort to end water shutoffs, which disproportionately harm Black communities. Water shutoffs also put vulnerable people at greater risk for malnutrition, contracting illness, and even death before, during, and after this pandemic. The coalition is advocating for water to be billed at affordable rates, such as a sliding scale based on household income so low-income people pay a lower rate for the water they need to survive. “Because of the City’s history of failed projects to address the water shutoffs crisis, we remain skeptical of Mayor Duggan’s December announcement that his administration will work on a ‘permanent water affordability solution at the state and federal level.’ If the City is serious, it will agree to a court order that requires the administration to make good on the Mayor’s promise,” said Mark Fancher, ACLU of Michigan Racial Justice Project staff attorney. “A moratorium on water shutoffs is essential to deal with the current emergency, but it is not a permanent solution. Detroit officials must find new approaches to billing and collection and put an end to the cruel and racist tactic of shutting off residents’ running water for outstanding balances that are unaffordable.” “Low-income residents must be able to afford their water bills in order for them to lead healthy and secure lives in their own homes, and for the city to collect utility payments,” said Coty Montag, Senior Counsel at LDF. “Black communities must have access to clean, affordable water. Rather than expend efforts to throw out our lawsuit, we urge city and state officials to instate a meaningful water affordability plan and end the racial discrimination resulting from Detroit’s water shutoff policy.” WHO:Coty Montag, LDF Senior CounselJason Bailey, LDF Special Economic CounselMark Fancher, ACLU Racial Justice Project Staff Attorney WHEN:Wednesday, February 3, 2021, immediately following the hearing.To watch the hearing in U.S. District Court, you may request access to in−court proceedings at: www.mied.uscourts.gov ZOOM PRESS CONFERENCE LOGIN:Join online:https://aclu.zoom.us/j/83729842681?pwd=RWFnTzFFKy9POXE5cHFqOXhuNVpLUT09 Or join by phone: (877) 853-5247Meeting ID: 837 2984 2681Passcode: 380636 This press conference will also be live-streamed on the ACLU of Michigan Facebook page. Case background, filings, and work on this issue over the years are at:https://www.aclumich.org/en/cases/water-shutoffs-detroit ###You are invited to join virtual court proceedings this Wed, Feb. 3rd at 9:30am ET in the case, Taylor et al v. Detroit, City of, et al(case 2:20-cv-11860-DPH-APP) in U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan, for which People’s Water Board Coalition is a plaintiff.See Zoom video link and phone numbers below. Class Action Complaint — JACQUELINE TAYLOR, LISA BROOKS, MICHELE COWAN, TUANA HENRY, MATTIE MCCORKLE, RENEE WILSON, and PEOPLE’S WATER BOARD COALITION, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated,Plaintiffsv.CITY OF DETROIT, a Municipal Corporation, through the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department, its Agent; GOVERNOR GRETCHEN WHITMER, in her official capacity; MAYOR MICHAEL DUGGAN, in his official capacity; and GARY BROWN, in his official capacity.Defendants.Plaintiffs’ (excellent!) attorneys include: Mark Fancher, ACLU of Michigan Racial Justice Project; Alice B. Jennings, founding partner of Edwards & Jennings, PC; Coty Montag, Senior Counsel for the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.; Lorray Brown of the Michigan Poverty Law Program; Monique Lin-Luse and Jason Bailey of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.; Dan Korobkin and Bonsitu Kitaba- Gaviglio of the ACLU of Michigan; and Detroit attorneys Melissa El Johnson and Kurt Thornbladh. For the Defendants, the State of Michigan’s attorney is Mark Sands and the City of Detroit’s attorney is Hallom Stanton. In brief, the Defendants have filed a Motion to Dismiss this case because Detroit Mayor Duggan has announced water services will not be disconnected through the year 2022. However, this is not definitive and doesn’t guarantee water service shut offs will be permanently ended — plus, there is no water affordability policy and a temporary stoppage isn’t enough. Per Attorney Jennings, the Plaintiffs’ attorneys have filed responses to the Defendants’ Motions protesting the dismissal of this class action case.ZoomGov Webinar: https://www.zoomgov.com/j/1619386023?pwd=MFhDUEpIMGZrak1vZkIwQWhzOE9iUT09Passcode: 494470 One-tap Mobile: +16692545252,,1619386023# Or Call: 669-254-5252 Webinar ID: 161 938 6023 Passcode: 494470Please share widely and pack the online court!

Read More »

People’s Water Board Coalition Applauds Detroit Mayor’s Decision to Ban Water Shutoffs and Restore Residential Water

Detroit, MI (December 8, 2020) — The People’s Water Board Coalition applauds Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan and the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD) for following the long-standing recommendations of water advocates, public health experts, and impacted residents to end the practice of DWSD water shutoffs. The devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on Detroiters, in particular, has made it abundantly clear that to protect public health DWSD cannot deny residential water service to the City’s residents.  Two decades of disconnected water service to Detroit residents unable to afford the cost of exponential rate increases and high sewage bills have resulted in many disproportionate health and quality of life consequences. Mayor Duggan’s announcement of the steps to be taken today by the City of Detroit will help alleviate the deadly toll that the public health crisis has taken on our communities.  “Universal access to safe drinking water is a matter of life and death. By eliminating water shutoffs through 2022 is a step in the right direction. In the short-term, Detroit’s leaders are taking the necessary and humane approach to providing drinking water to everyone, regardless of income,” stated Sylvia Orduño, an organizer with Michigan Welfare Rights Organization and the People’s Water Board Coalition. However, this is not the end of the problem. “We appreciate the Mayor’s stated commitment to addressing the long-term problems with water affordability in Detroit,” continued Orduño. “But we need affordable water rates based on residents’ ability to pay their water bills. The Water Rate Assistance Program isn’t an affordability program. Federal water assistance is welcome, but it is not an affordability program and doesn’t address the underlying problem of unaffordable water rates.” “There are still many Detroit residents who are living under the radar because they are afraid,” said Rosyln Walker, a People’s Water Board Coalition canvassing coordinator. “They do not have running water or have turned on water themselves because they still can’t afford to pay the high bills.”  Since the turn of the century the People’s Water Board Coalition and our partners have fought to end the practice of water shut offs and institute income-based affordability measures. Last spring when Governor Whitmer acknowledged advocates’ concerns and put Executive Orders 2020-28 and 2020-144 in place to mandate water restoration during the pandemic, People’s Water Board Coalition was pleased with Detroit leadership to assist residents. Although the Michigan Supreme Court acted on partisan lines and invalidated the Governor’s authority to guarantee running water during a pandemic, Mayor Duggan stepped in to ensure that Detroiters have water service to wash their hands as the pandemic continues.  The reporting requirements put in place by the Governor’s executive order last spring show that the water affordability and shut off crisis is not just a Detroit problem. Thousands of Michiganders outside of Detroit are facing drowning in unaffordable water bills and face the threat of water shut offs. Detroiters will be protected by the action that Mayor Duggan is taking today, but too many Michiganders are vulnerable to water shut offs. The People’s Water Board Coalition urges lawmakers in Lansing to immediately pass Senate Bill 241 as a bipartisan issue, which will ensure statewide access to safe running water while the pandemic continues.  “The risk of water shut offs and life without running water isn’t a partisan issue,” continued Orduño. “Tragically, Republicans and Democrats in the Michigan legislature have hundreds of thousands of constituents who risk losing access to running water.”  ### The People’s Water Board Coalition believes that all people have a human right to clean, accessible, and affordable water and sanitation. We are a coalition of three dozen grassroots groups, NGO’s, faith-based, community-based, and labor organizations who have come together to advocate against water insecurity alongside impacted residents. Nearly 200,000 residents in Detroit have experienced water shutoffs since 2002 when community organizers began working on a water affordability plan and fighting for the human rights to water and sanitation. The People’s Water Board formed in 2009 amidst a deepening crisis of water access and affordability. 

Read More »

We Demand An Income-Based Water Affordability Plan Be Implemented

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASENews from People’s Water Board CoalitionJuly 9, 2020Contact: Lynna Kaucheck, (586) 556-8805, lynna@engagemichigan.orgGovernor’s Action Proves Need for Income-Based Water BillsWater is a basic human need, water shut-offs should be stopped permanently. DETROIT – In light of Governor Whitmer’s Executive Order yesterday extending the Executive Order on the restoration of public water services that have been shut-off through the end of the year the People’s Water Board Coalition released the following statement:“The Governor’s extension of the order for water restoration acknowledges what we’ve known for a long time: families like mine who have been forced to live without water experience serious health threats when we don’t have access to water to wash our hands, which is the number one way to stop the spread of the disease,” said Nicole Hill from the People’s Water Board Coalition. “We all need water to drink, wash, and for sanitation, and while this extension is a step in the right direction it is imperative that the state takes quick action to end water shut-offs for good. The City of Detroit must restore service where it has been disconnected and implement an income-based water affordability program.” The People’s Water Board Coalition is suing the Governor, Detroit Mayor Duggan, and Detroit Water and Sewerage Department Director Gary Brown, they seek to permanently end water shut-offs and implement an income-based water affordability program, and to protect publichealth. “Now is the time to act, pandemic or not, people can’t live without water. Governor Whitmer and Mayor Duggan must work together to ensure that all Michigan residents, particularly in Detroit and Flint, have access to the water and sanitation we need to keep our families and communities healthy,” adds Sylvia Orduño from the People’s Water Board Coalition.

Read More »
MCWC logo

News Release on Nestle Challenge by Michigan Citizens for Water Conservation April 27, 2020

The April 24 ruling by Administrative Law Judge Daniel L. Pulter issued onbehalf of the Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy(formerly MDEQ) upheld the permit issued to Nestle Corporation by theMDEQ to pump water from the White Pine Springs well in Evart (PW-101)at a rate of 400 gallons per minute. The Contested Case brought forth byMichigan Citizens for Water Conservation and the Grand Traverse Band ofOttawa and Chippewa Indians was denied. EGLE successfully argued on behalf of Nestle and in support of theoriginal permit decision granted to Nestle by the Snyder administration onApril 2, 2018 following over a year of public comment and protest. Nestlehad been granted a permit to withdraw at 150 gpm in March of 2009. It wasgiven an additional permit, without public notice or comment, to addanother 100 gpm in April of 2015, thus pumping at 250. In July of 2016 Nestle applied for the contested permit to increase to 400gpm. Notice was given to the public in obscure publications and we werenot aware of it until notified by a reporter in October when there were only 4 days left of the public comment period. MCWC and others mounted acampaign for comment and the response was so overwhelming inopposition to the permit that the comment period was extended twice, anda public hearing was forced for the spring of 2017. Over 600 peopleappeared in Big Rapids, 50 testified against the permit, and commentswere ultimately taken from roughly 80,000 people with only a handfulsupporting the permit. It was nevertheless granted by Snyder’s MDEQunder the leadership of former BP spokesperson Heidi Grether in April of2018. MCWC filed a petition for a contested case hearing and was joined by theGrand Traverse Band. Many other organizations voiced support for ourpetition. There was eventually hope that the new administration, givennumerous campaign promises to reign in the power of corporations toexploit our natural resources, would come to the aid of the petitioners andassist us in interpreting the existing legal frameworks to demonstrate the basic flaws in allowing computer models to over-ride the real time datagenerated by past precedent in Mecosta and current conditions in Evartafter pumping at 250 gpm. This did not happen. In fact, we were never even given the courtesy of aface to face meeting with the Attorney General’s office or the director ofEGLE. We were invited to attend the public relations events held by EGLEbut were told we could not discuss the Nestle permits because we were inlitigation. Of course, Nestle was in constant contact with EGLE staff and theAssistant Attorneys general assigned to the case since they were arguingon behalf of Nestle’s permits throughout. At no time did the organs of theState see fit to consult with or support the petitioners who were asking theState to exercise its public trust responsibility to defend the waters of thecommons from exploitation and depletion. So, we were not surprised that our efforts did not result in victory in thecourt of EGLE, even after a lengthy and expensive legal battle. In the courtof public opinion, we had won long ago. The Court of Appeals had upheldthe right of Osceola Township to exercise its zoning rights and deny Nestlea booster station that was not deemed in the public interest. The injustice of Nestle’s water grab, strictly for corporate profit, while manycitizens still are without clean water throughout the state, has been wellunderstood, particularly in this time of a major health crisis that demandswater access in something other than expensive plastic bottles. Nestle hasprofited greatly from the Flint water disaster, about to witness a sixthanniversary with no justice still in sight for those responsible. The trucks roll out of the Stanwood bottling plant with even more profit as the corona virus prompts people to clear the store shelves under the false notion that bottled water is essential even for those who already have public water systems that are working. Public pressure from non-profits finally forced the Governor to act to restore public water to Detroiters who had been shut off, though those still without were given more bottled water as Nestle profit mounted. Nestle’s world-wide campaign to promote private bottled water at theexpense of affordable public infrastructure is producing predictableconsequences during the current Covid-19 crisis. Those who don’t needbottled water are hoarding it and those who cannot get public infrastructure funded and fixed are forced to rely on it to get through the crisis. Unfortunately, the laws of our state still allow private corporations to profitfrom our natural resources but do not seem to support public health andwelfare. Those laws must change so that the human right to clean,affordable water and sanitation becomes the top priority of government,rather than the promotion of corporate greed and destruction ofenvironmental support systems. MCWC intends to continue its education and advocacy work on behalf ofwater justice, and in opposition to the pollution, plunder and privatization of the waters of the Great Lakes Basin. This recent set-back, the remnant ofantiquated laws and the continuing control of our governments by largecorporations, is a temporary set-back. A new world is going to emerge fromthe current crises, and justice will have to guide us in mounting the evengreater existential challenge to control the climate crisis. The lessonslearned now will inform the rising movement to achieve a livable future forour children. This little set-back, in one insignificant court, will not deter usfrom continuing our challenges to business-as-usual or our determination to enact laws and policies that actually serve all the people and preserve our ecosystems. Michigan Citizens for Water ConservationsaveMIwater.org Email: info@saveMIwater.org Contact person:Peggy Case231-275-2244hildaheron@aol.com

Read More »

Statement on Gov Whitmer Inaction on Water Shutoffs, Public Health Safety

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE News from the People’s Water Board  Friday, February 28, 2020 Contact: Kim Hunter kim@engagemichigan.org 313-287-2992 Groups Demand Whitmer Enact Water Shutoff Moratorium to Fight Coronavirus Public health endangered by depriving thousands of clean water DETROIT – Today, a large coalition of social justice groups released a statement which serves as the basis for a letter and a petition to Governor Gretchen Whitmer. In the document, they call on Governor Whitmer to use her executive authority to declare a moratorium on water shutoffs because of the current and impending health crisis. The groups cite the need for everyone to have access to clean, safe water as a way to combat the spread of coronavirus which the Centers for Disease Control affirm will spread in the United States. They have  released the following statement:  In light of the impending health and social crisis of coronavirus and the current health crisis of shigellosis and other water-related illnesses caused by thousands of households being deprived of water, we the undersigned demand that Governor Gretchen Whitmer work with the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services to call for an immediate moratorium on all water shutoffs in the State of Michigan.  Hundreds of thousands of people in low-income families across the state have borne the brunt of the record rise in the cost of water services and the unaffordable water bills that have resulted from that rise. The unconscionable act of depriving anyone of water because the cost is more than they can afford has resulted in a health crisis, that, with the advent of coronavirus, has the serious potential to be magnified and spread due to thousands not having access to water.  The ultimate solution is to implement income based water bills based on the Water Affordability Plan. The immediate, short term solution must be a moratorium on water shutoffs and the immediate restoration of service where it’s been disconnected. U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Alex M. Azar II declared a public health emergency for the entire United States to aid the nation’s healthcare community in responding to COVID-19 (coronavirus.) The World Health Organization has already declared a public health emergency, naming it an issue of international concern. For this reason, it is incumbent upon us to ensure that all Michigan residents have access to clean, safe, and affordable water. We must stop the water shutoffs that are occurring in our communities to prevent the further spread of potentially fatal infectious diseases such as COVID-19. The City of Detroit, Michigan’s largest city, became the first major city in the world to shut off hundreds of thousands of its most vulnerable residents from water and sanitation, flouting the consensus of an international body of research that shows water, sanitation, and hygiene access are essential to maintaining mental and physical health, and to halting the spread of infectious disease. The Centers for Disease Control recommendations for common prevention strategies include the following specifically:   Wash your hands often with soap and water for at least 20 seconds, especially after going to the bathroom; before eating; and after blowing your nose, coughing, or sneezing. If soap and water are not readily available, use an alcohol-based hand sanitizer with at least 60% alcohol. Always wash hands with soap and water if hands are visibly dirty. Michigan residents have particular reason to fear the spread of coronavirus because the ongoing deprivation of tens of thousands of people from basic access to water and sanitation puts everyone at risk Residents deprived of water in their homes have been sharing or borrowing water at an alarming rate — 80% in one study — creating a transmission path for coronavirus, as well as hepatitis A, shigellosis, campylobacter, and giardia, all of which have been plausibly linked to the shutoffs by health officials The city and state have neglected to put any public health measures in place or to study the problem Those shutoff from water are already more likely to be infants or children, elders, and/or people living with chronic illness — the same factors that predispose people to a more serious course of illness or death if they catch the virus It should not take an outbreak to realize that lack of water and sanitation poses a danger to the public health of those impacted by shutoffs, and everyone in our state Governor Whitmer must act in the best interests of every person in the State of Michigan. Basic health and safety must be the top priority. The threat of widespread disease makes it imperative that every household has access to clean, safe water for drinking and sanitation. That means the Governor must use her authority to declare a moratorium on water shutoffs across the state.     Rabbi Alana Alpert, Executive Director, Detroit Jews for Justice Charles Altman Russ Bellant, former licensed Water Plant Treatment Operator, City of Detroit. Randy Block, Director, Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network Rev. Roslyn Bouier, Executive Director, Brightmoor Connection, Detroit People’s Platform, Equitable Detroit Coalition Jennifer Carrera, Assistant Professor of Sociology, Michigan State University Piper Carter, Hartwell Block Club Environmental Justice & Equity Cultural Organizer  Rev. Cass Charrette, People’s Water Board, Poor People’s Campaign Detroit People’s Platform Faculty-Staff-Student Alliance for Climate and the Environment (FSSACE), Oakland University Jennifer Fassbender, Coalition to Oppose the Expansion of US Ecology Barbara Ford, R.N., President of Davison Association of Block Clubs Nadia Gaber, PhD University of California San Francisco/UC Berkeley, We the People of Detroit Community Research Collective  Georgia Street Collective Mary Grant, Public Water for all Campaign Director, Food & Water Action  Rev. Denise Griebler, St. Peter’s Episcopal Church, Detroit; Michigan Coalition for Human Rights Mary Ellen Howard, RSM, Sisters of Mercy, People’s Water Board Dr. Shea Howell,  James and Grace Lee Boggs Center to Nurture Community Leadership Kim Hunter, Engage Michigan Darryl Jordan Co-Director, East Michigan Environmental Action Council/Cass Corridor Commons    Alice B. Jennings, Partner, Edwards &Jennings, PC Marian Kramer, Michigan Welfare Rights Organization; Highland Park Human Rights Coalition Emily Kutil, University at Buffalo,

Read More »

About

The People’s Water Board Coalition advocates for the human rights to water and sanitation and equitable access and affordability for impacted communities.

Contact

2022 People's Water Board Coalition